top of page

The Mysterious Circleville Letters: Unveiling the Enigma

In the late 1970s, the quiet town of Circleville, Ohio was shaken to its core by a series of enigmatic letters that mysteriously appeared in mailboxes. Postmarked from Columbus, Ohio, these letters contained cryptic messages, threats, and accusations targeting various community members. The identity of the elusive Circleville Writer, responsible for these unsettling letters, remains one of the most perplexing mysteries to this day. Join us as we delve into the unsettling story of the Circleville Letters and the chilling impact they had on this small Ohio town.

The Infamous Letter: In 1983, Mary Gillespie, a local bus driver, received a letter that would send shockwaves through Circleville. The letter, signed by the Circleville Writer, exposed an alleged affair between Mary and the school superintendent. What made it even more terrifying was the detailed knowledge the writer had of Mary's daily routine, indicating they had been closely observing her. Fearing for her safety, Mary turned to her husband Ron and her sister-in-law Karen for support.

A Husband's Desperate Quest: Determined to uncover the truth behind the letters, Ron took it upon himself to investigate. He staked out the Columbus post office, hoping to catch a glimpse of the mysterious writer. But before he could gather any substantial leads, Ron's truck was targeted in a chilling act of violence—an unknown assailant opened fire, leaving Ron alive but profoundly shaken.

The Unrelenting Letters: As Ron recovered from the shocking attack, the Circleville Letters continued to plague the community. Some were aimed at other residents, while others were directed specifically at Ron and Mary. The anonymous writer seemed relentless, spreading fear and uncertainty throughout Circleville.

A Twist in the Tale: In a surprising turn of events, Paul Freshour, a former colleague of Mary's, was arrested and charged with the attempted murder of Ron Gillespie. Paul had previously sent anonymous letters accusing Mary of an affair with the superintendent. However, even with Paul behind bars, the Circleville Letters persisted. An anonymous letter sent to Paul in jail accused him of being the Circleville Writer, casting doubt on his involvement in the sinister saga.

The Lingering Mystery: While Paul was ultimately convicted for the attempted murder, the identity of the Circleville Writer remains an unsolved mystery. The case continues to baffle investigators and true crime enthusiasts alike. The Circleville Letters have become the stuff of legend, leaving behind a chilling legacy that still fascinates those who delve into the dark side of human nature.

The perplexing tale of the Circleville Letters holds a grip on the collective imagination, as the identity of the enigmatic writer remains shrouded in darkness. This chilling story serves as a reminder of the profound impact of anonymous terror and the enduring power of unsolved mysteries. As the years pass, the haunting presence of the Circleville Letters continues to intrigue and captivate, leaving us to wonder if the truth behind this chilling enigma will ever come to light.

10 views0 comments


bottom of page